Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Judge must weigh nearly six hours of evidence in 1981 murder case

Billy Hawk, a bowling alley owner indicted in September 2015 in the 1981 slaying of Johnny Mack Salyer, appears with attorneys before Hamilton County Criminal Court Judge Don Poole to discuss if two pieces of evidence could exonerate him.
Billy Hawk, a bowling alley owner indicted in September 2015 in the 1981 slaying of Johnny Mack Salyer, appears with attorneys before Hamilton County Criminal Court Judge Don Poole to discuss if two pieces of evidence could exonerate him.

Could a 1981 murder case be dismissed?

Hamilton County Criminal Court Judge Don Poole said he will decide that before May 9, when attorneys reconvene to argue over Billy Hawk, the 62-year-old bowling alley owner accused of first-degree murder in the death of Johnny Mack Salyer. Attorneys spent another six hours Wednesday squaring off over evidence.

Defense lawyers Bill Speek, Jonathan Turner and Jim Logan reiterated their argument that two key pieces of evidence are missing: the original X-ray of Salyer’s torso and the 55-gallon steel drum that Salyer’s body was pulled from on June 3, 1981.

Speek and Logan focused on the missing X-ray by calling Teddy Ladd to the witness stand. Ladd said he used to take X-rays for the county’s medical examiner in 1981 and did so in the Hawk case.

On Tuesday, Ladd said he took one of Salyer’s chest before handing it over to the medical examiner.