Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Gerson: GOP Hoosiers pick between bad and worse

Donald Trump, Republican presidential hopeful, with former college basketball coach Bobby Knight during a campaign rally in the Aiken Theater, Evansville, Ind., on Thursday.
Donald Trump, Republican presidential hopeful, with former college basketball coach Bobby Knight during a campaign rally in the Aiken Theater, Evansville, Ind., on Thursday.

WASHINGTON – In a world where bullying is interpreted as strength, Donald Trump and Bobby Knight would be kings. One of them is testing the proposition.

Not Knight, though some in Indiana might prefer him. It is the hidden vice of polite, congenial Hoosiers that they regard the profane, chair-throwing, player-assaulting former Indiana University basketball coach as a legend. In a state where basketball is the fourth monotheistic religion, Knight’s public embrace of Trump – comparing him to George Washington and Harry Truman – might be one of those rare endorsements that make a difference, in a primary that Trump probably needs to win to secure the GOP presidential nomination on the first ballot.

Ted Cruz, in contrast, looks less like a winner every day. At the gym where home games in the movie “Hoosiers” were filmed, Cruz referred to the basketball hoop as a “ring.” The gaffe was particularly damaging because it reinforced a perception that Cruz is a political panderer, and an inept one.

At first glance, Indiana – an electorate heavy with conservatives and religious people – would seem to be favorable ground for Cruz’s last stand. But this interpretation ignores the current complexity of Hoosier politics.

Indiana’s Republican governor, Mike Pence, should be in a dominant position as he campaigns for re-election. The state’s economy is booming. Pence can take credit for the second-largest budget surplus in Indiana history. Yet a recent poll has the governor under 50 percent support and barely ahead of a politically mediocre Democratic challenger. More Hoosiers think their state is on the wrong track than the right one.