Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

No quick ruling in North Carolina same-sex marriage lawsuit

Lawyer Luke Largess, right, talks about his arguments in federal court on Monday, Aug. 8, 2016, that North Carolina's law allowing magistrates to opt out of performing gay marriages for religious reasons in unconstitutional and a lawsuit should be allowed to continue outside the federal courthouse in Asheville, N.C., as from left to right, plaintiff, Diane Ansley, lawyer Meghann Burke and plaintiff Cathy McGaughey, listen on Monday. (AP Photo/Jeffrey Collins)
Lawyer Luke Largess, right, talks about his arguments in federal court on Monday, Aug. 8, 2016, that North Carolina's law allowing magistrates to opt out of performing gay marriages for religious reasons in unconstitutional and a lawsuit should be allowed to continue outside the federal courthouse in Asheville, N.C., as from left to right, plaintiff, Diane Ansley, lawyer Meghann Burke and plaintiff Cathy McGaughey, listen on Monday. (AP Photo/Jeffrey Collins)

RALEIGH, N.C. (AP) – A federal judge seems inclined to let a legal challenge continue over North Carolina’s law allowing magistrates to refuse to marry same-sex couples, but only if those suing can prove they have the right to file the legal action.

U.S. District Judge Max Cogburn didn’t rule immediately after Monday’s hearing in Asheville, but seemed concerned about two issues. On one hand, he said no one had directly proven they had been harmed by the law. But he also noted that court administrators apparently allow magistrates to keep their objections secret, so gay couples who appear before them on other matters wouldn’t know about those objections.

Lawyers for the state want Cogburn to throw out the lawsuit. The judge said he found their arguments persuasive that gay couples couldn’t say they were being harmed as taxpayers, since the law requires another magistrate to be brought in for gay marriage duties.

“Everybody can get married. And nobody is forced to marry anybody,” said Cogburn, an appointee of President Barack Obama who was the first judge to strike down North Carolina’s gay marriage law two years ago.

Roughly 5 percent of North Carolina’s magistrates are refusing to marry same-sex couples for religious reasons, including every magistrate in McDowell County. A magistrate is being brought in from another county for gay marriages.