A federal judge has denied claims by 911 emergency management districts in Hamilton County and nine other Tennessee communities that AT&T shortchanged the districts millions of dollars in telephone fees.
Nearly five years after the lawsuit was filed against AT&T, U.S. District Court Judge Curtis Collier this week ruled that AT&T was not liable to pay the 911 districts more money on charges the districts claim should have been collected from consumers and used for 911 services.
The Hamilton County Emergency Management District sued AT&T in 2011, claiming the telephone giant was not collecting enough fees from business telephone users under the requirements adopted by the Tennessee Legislature in 1998 to help fund enhanced 911 services. Nine other emergency districts, including Knoxville, joined in the suit.
The lawsuit said AT&T had not provided information about the number or type of lines to the local agencies and cited instances in which AT&T failed to bill the required $3 monthly fee on some business lines.
To help pay for 911 services, the state requires telephone companies to collect fees from their customers and turn over such fees to local emergency management districts that handle 911 calls and dispatch police, fire and medical units. Consumers pay a $1.50 monthly surcharge for residential land lines and $3 per month for business lines.
