Skip to main content
Friday, November 13, 2026Nov 13

Judge tough but fair in black man-police custody death case

In this undated photo released by the Maryland Judiciary Office of Communications and Public Affairs, Baltimore Circuit Judge Barry Williams poses for a photo. Judge Williams  who's overseeing the emotionally charged case of a young black man who died in police custody is a former federal prosecutor who used to put dirty police officers on trial. Friends and colleagues describe Baltimore Circuit Judge Williams as an even-handed judge who has a sense of humor but doesn’t tolerate any courtroom grandstanding. People on both sides of the Freddie Gray case agree that he is the best judge for the job.(Maryland Judiciary Office of Communications and Public Affairs via AP)
In this undated photo released by the Maryland Judiciary Office of Communications and Public Affairs, Baltimore Circuit Judge Barry Williams poses for a photo. Judge Williams who's overseeing the emotionally charged case of a young black man who died in police custody is a former federal prosecutor who used to put dirty police officers on trial. Friends and colleagues describe Baltimore Circuit Judge Williams as an even-handed judge who has a sense of humor but doesn’t tolerate any courtroom grandstanding. People on both sides of the Freddie Gray case agree that he is the best judge for the job.(Maryland Judiciary Office of Communications and Public Affairs via AP)

BALTIMORE (AP) – The judge overseeing the emotionally charged case of a young black man who died in police custody is a former federal prosecutor who used to put dirty police officers on trial.

Friends and colleagues describe Baltimore Circuit Judge Barry Williams, an African-American, as an even-handed judge who has a sense of humor but doesn’t tolerate any courtroom grandstanding. People on both sides of the Freddie Gray case agree he is the best judge for the job.

Williams will decide perhaps the most important trial in the Gray case. Officer Caesar Goodson faces a second-degree murder charge in the death of Gray, whose neck was broken in the back of a police wagon last spring. Goodson waived his right to a jury in favor of placing his fate in Williams’ hands. His trial begins Thursday.

Similarly, Officer Edward Nero, who faced assault and other charges in Gray’s death, opted for a bench trial. Williams acquitted Nero of all charges last month.

Williams’ verdict in the Nero trial was so narrowly focused it gave little indication of how he might rule for the van officer, who prosecutors say is the most culpable for Gray’s death.