Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Attorneys: Tennessee Supreme Court nudged to reconsider 110-year-old case

gavel
gavel

It’s stopped the five adopted children of the late Astec Industries CEO J. Don Brock from contesting their father’s estate twice now – a 110-year legal decision known as “the Cowan rule.”

But thanks to a rare “nudge” by an appeals judge, the Tennessee Supreme Court may take up the 1906 case and reconsider its long-standing precedent, attorneys said Friday.

Since September 2015, the siblings have argued their father’s second wife and former secretary, Sammye Brock, teamed up with two other adopted children – Sammye Brock’s from a previous marriage – to axe them from a 2013 will. Brock died in March 2015 of mesothelioma.

Last week, the Tennessee Court of Appeals in Knoxville agreed with a local court that upheld J. Don Brock’s will – albeit grudgingly, said Marya Schalk, one of the attorneys representing the siblings.

“It seems like the court had a problem reaching the decision it reached because of Cowan,” Schalk said.