Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Judge won’t reverse high school football playoff result

In this Saturday, Nov. 19, 2016, Plainfield North's Dillon McCarthy, center, celebrates with teammates after running into the end zone to complete a two-point conversion to beat Fenwick 18-17 in overtime in the Class 7A semifinal high school football game at Triton College in Oak Park, Ill. Fenwick High School, who lost athe playoff football game because officials made an incorrect call, won't be in the state championship contest after a judge on Wednesday rejected its bid to overturn the outcome.  (Eric P. Davis/Chicago Tribune via AP)
In this Saturday, Nov. 19, 2016, Plainfield North's Dillon McCarthy, center, celebrates with teammates after running into the end zone to complete a two-point conversion to beat Fenwick 18-17 in overtime in the Class 7A semifinal high school football game at Triton College in Oak Park, Ill. Fenwick High School, who lost athe playoff football game because officials made an incorrect call, won't be in the state championship contest after a judge on Wednesday rejected its bid to overturn the outcome. (Eric P. Davis/Chicago Tribune via AP)

CHICAGO (AP) – An Illinois high school football team that lost a playoff football game because officials made an incorrect call won’t be in the state championship contest after a judge on Wednesday rejected its bid to overturn the outcome.

Judge Kathleen Kennedy’s rejected an unusual lawsuit from Chicago suburban Fenwick High School seeking to reverse the Plainfield North High School victory last Saturday. Fenwick said it would not appeal the decision.

That sends Plainfield North High School to Saturday’s Class A state title game against East St. Louis. But none of the parties involved was celebrating.

Fenwick led the playoff game 10-7 and had the ball on fourth down on its own 15-yard line with four seconds left. The Fenwick quarterback heaved the ball downfield and used up the time left on the clock. Officials ruled the play to be intentional grounding, a penalty that gave Plainfield North the ball and one more play, which it used to kick a field goal and tie the game before winning 18-17 in overtime.

The Illinois High School Association, which governs prep sports in the state, said that under the rules the game should have ended after the pass – even with the penalty – because the clock ran out. The association apologized to Fenwick, but said there was no way for the school to appeal the outcome through the organization.