Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Palestinian accused of negligent homicide in police shooting

FILE -- In this Monday Sept. 5, 2016 file photo, Palestinians look at the car in which the driver, Ali Nimr, was wounded and passenger, Mustafa Nimr was killed by Israeli border police in Shuafat refugee camp in Jerusalem.  When Ali Nimr drove drunk at night past Israeli police operating in his Jerusalem neighborhood, the officers riddled the Palestinian’s car with gunfire, fearing he was an attacker, according to his indictment. Nimr’s brother-in-law, in the front seat next to him, was killed. The fatal shooting of Mustafa Nimr last month illustrates the sometimes murky circumstances in which dozens of alleged Palestinian assailants have been shot over the course of a year of violence. (AP Photo/Mahmoud Illean, File)
FILE -- In this Monday Sept. 5, 2016 file photo, Palestinians look at the car in which the driver, Ali Nimr, was wounded and passenger, Mustafa Nimr was killed by Israeli border police in Shuafat refugee camp in Jerusalem. When Ali Nimr drove drunk at night past Israeli police operating in his Jerusalem neighborhood, the officers riddled the Palestinian’s car with gunfire, fearing he was an attacker, according to his indictment. Nimr’s brother-in-law, in the front seat next to him, was killed. The fatal shooting of Mustafa Nimr last month illustrates the sometimes murky circumstances in which dozens of alleged Palestinian assailants have been shot over the course of a year of violence. (AP Photo/Mahmoud Illean, File)

JERUSALEM (AP) – When Ali Nimr drove drunk at night past Israeli police operating in his Jerusalem neighborhood, the officers sprayed the Palestinian’s car with gunfire, fearing he was an attacker, according to his indictment. Nimr’s brother-in-law, in the front seat next to him, was killed.

Now Nimr is on trial for negligent homicide in his death.

The fatal shooting of Mustafa Nimr illustrates the sometimes murky circumstances in which dozens of alleged Palestinian assailants have been shot over the course of a year of violence.

In every instance, Israeli police and troops have said they opened fire only after Palestinians posed a life-threatening danger to them, usually by attempting to stab them or ram them with a car. But Palestinians say this explanation has been used to cover up numerous cases in which Israel either used excessive force to halt assailants or needlessly killed people who were not attackers.

“Should a man who is making a turn, even while speeding, in his own neighborhood in the dark of night know there is a hidden squad there manning a checkpoint and shooting at people?” asked Waseem Dakwar, who is defending Ali Nimr in the trial, which began Thursday.