Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Sohn: Withholding Charlotte police video builds distrust

A man leaves flowers in the parking lot where Keith Scott was shot dead by a police officer in Charlotte, N.C., this week. The incident has triggered violent clashes between police and protesters. (Logan R. Cyrus/The New York Times)
A man leaves flowers in the parking lot where Keith Scott was shot dead by a police officer in Charlotte, N.C., this week. The incident has triggered violent clashes between police and protesters. (Logan R. Cyrus/The New York Times)

Communities like Charlotte – psychologically and at times physically torn apart by anger over real or perceived police bias or inadequate training – should take a breath and step toward openness.

Instead, they far too often hide behind the words “under investigation” – as Charlotte authorities are doing now.

Charlotte-Mecklenburg Police Chief Kerr Putney said Thursday that he has no plans to release the video of the shooting that killed Keith L. Scott earlier this week, though he does intend to show it to the man’s family.

Scott, 43, was shot while officers were serving a warrant on someone else. There are starkly different accounts about what happened. The police say Scott, who had been sitting in his car waiting for his son, got out of the car and was holding a gun before he was shot; friends and family say he held a book.

A new North Carolina law will go into effect in a few weeks that can stop the public from seeing police shooting video, and community residents calling for the video’s release immediately have said they wonder if the chief is not stalling until that law becomes effective. The chief has countered that to protect the integrity of an investigation, it is not the department’s practice to release video to the public.