Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Judge won’t reinstate girls after boys’ basketball dispute

FILE- In this Aug. 3, 2017, file photo, Scott Phillips, left, looks on as his wife Theresa Mullen, center, talk to their attorney Susan Brandt McCrea during the trial in Newark, N.J. The parents of Sydney Phillips and her younger sister, Kaitlyn are seeking a court order to allow the girls to return to their Catholic school in Kenilworth after a dispute over one of them wanting to play on the boys basketball team. A judge on Monday, Aug. 14, refused to overturn a decision to banish the two sisters from their Roman Catholic school after a dispute over one of them wanting to play on the boys basketball team. (Aristide Economopoulos/NJ Advance Media via AP, Pool)
FILE- In this Aug. 3, 2017, file photo, Scott Phillips, left, looks on as his wife Theresa Mullen, center, talk to their attorney Susan Brandt McCrea during the trial in Newark, N.J. The parents of Sydney Phillips and her younger sister, Kaitlyn are seeking a court order to allow the girls to return to their Catholic school in Kenilworth after a dispute over one of them wanting to play on the boys basketball team. A judge on Monday, Aug. 14, refused to overturn a decision to banish the two sisters from their Roman Catholic school after a dispute over one of them wanting to play on the boys basketball team. (Aristide Economopoulos/NJ Advance Media via AP, Pool)

NEWARK, N.J. (AP) – A judge in New Jersey has refused to overturn a Roman Catholic school’s decision to deny re-enrollment to two sisters after a dispute over one of them wanting to play on the boys basketball team.

“The court does not have the authority to meddle in this decision,” Superior Court Judge Donald Kessler said in his ruling on Monday.

Kessler lashed out at the girls’ parents for making the dispute public, and said the family did not cite any law that would have allowed the court to interfere with the religious school’s decision.

Cardinal Joseph Tobin testified that he decided not to allow 13-year-old Sydney Phillips and her younger sister, Kaitlyn, to re-enroll because their parents’ behavior was not in the best interest of St. Theresa School in Kenilworth.

The dispute began when Sydney Phillips was not allowed to play on the boys basketball team.