Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Cleaveland: Rushed legislation is no way to pass health care fix

The SafeSEAL(TM) antimicrobial soft diaphram slips onto any stethoscope effortlessly. Changed only once a week, SafeSEAL(TM)  helps provide protection against harmful bacteria commonly found on stethoscopes. Available in adult, pediatric and infant sizes. (PRNewsFoto)
The SafeSEAL(TM) antimicrobial soft diaphram slips onto any stethoscope effortlessly. Changed only once a week, SafeSEAL(TM) helps provide protection against harmful bacteria commonly found on stethoscopes. Available in adult, pediatric and infant sizes. (PRNewsFoto)

Facing a Sept. 30 deadline to pass legislation to repeal and replace the Affordable Care Act of 2010 (ACA), Republican Sens. Lindsay Graham and Bill Cassidy are vigorously pushing a proposal (GCA) to overhaul America’s health care system. Sens. Dean Heller and Ron Johnson are co-sponsors.

Under Senate rules, this measure can be approved by a simple majority before month’s end. A 50-50 tie could be broken by the affirmative vote of Vice President Mike Pence. House Speaker Paul Ryan promises immediate approval by the House if the Senate bill beats the deadline.

Given the rush to a vote in the Senate, there is little chance that public hearings can be held to analyze the GCA and to debate its merits and shortcomings. Provider and patient groups will have no opportunity to voice their concerns. As of Sept. 21 , opposition to the GCA has been expressed by the American Medical Association, the American College of Physicians and the American Academy of Family Practice.

Organizations opposing the GCA include the American Cancer Society, American Diabetes Association, National Lung Association, Arthritis Foundation and National Organization for Women. The AARP has added its strong opposition. America’s Health Insurance Plans foresees chaos if the GCA passes. Lists of opponents will grow as content of the ACA is publicized.

photo Dr. Clif Cleaveland

Normally, the nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office (CBO) carries out a detailed analysis of cost and impact for important pieces of legislation. A full CBO report on the GCA is impossible before the Sept. 30 deadline.