Skip to main content
Friday, October 30, 2026Oct 30

This story is free to read.

Smith: Debating same topics over and over and expecting something different is social insanity

Hamilton County Mayor Jim Coppinger, lower left, applauds as Marie Williams, Commissioner of the Tennessee Department of Mental Health and Substance Abuse Services, delivers a $350,000 grant to Chris Wyre, President and CEO of Volunteer Behavioral Health Friday at the Johnson Mental Health Center in Chattanooga. Hamilton County Sheriff Jim Hammond, Chattanooga Police Chief David Roddy, Judge Don Poole and Judge Lila Staton were in attendance for the presentation. The monies are directed for a pre-arrest diversion program.
Hamilton County Mayor Jim Coppinger, lower left, applauds as Marie Williams, Commissioner of the Tennessee Department of Mental Health and Substance Abuse Services, delivers a $350,000 grant to Chris Wyre, President and CEO of Volunteer Behavioral Health Friday at the Johnson Mental Health Center in Chattanooga. Hamilton County Sheriff Jim Hammond, Chattanooga Police Chief David Roddy, Judge Don Poole and Judge Lila Staton were in attendance for the presentation. The monies are directed for a pre-arrest diversion program. Hamilton County Mayor Jim Coppinger, lower left, applauds as Marie Williams, Commissioner of the Tennessee Department of Mental Health and Substance Abuse Services, delivers a $350,000 grant to Chris Wyre, President and CEO of Volunteer Behavioral Health Friday at the Johnson Mental Health Center in Chattanooga. Hamilton County Sheriff Jim Hammond, Chattanooga Police Chief David Roddy, Judge Don Poole and Judge Lila Staton were in attendance for the presentation. The monies are directed for a pre-arrest diversion program.

As a child I read the Scripture about Jesus healing a man possessed by evil spirits (Mark, Chapter 5) many times, and I prayed that Jesus would heal my mentally ill mother as he healed that man in the cemetery. Dealing with the mentally ill is not a new issue for me. I have no doubt the family and adopted families of Nikolas Cruz, the Florida school shooter, prayed earnestly for their son before his horrific acts in February.

Families like mine, as well as psychologists, police and counselors who deal with the mentally ill, face difficult decisions that many of us who live in a “normal” world cannot fathom. As a society, our failure to help care for the mentally ill will continue to haunt us, as Cruz and others have blatantly displayed.

After the shooting, many activists rushed to do something. But, doing “something” is not the same as solving problems. We have the same gun control arguments over and over. Common-sense gun laws are needed; however, during the first murder in recorded history, Cain killed his brother Abel without a gun. Should we also outlaw knives, rocks and sticks? Instead, the focus should be on the common denominator in mass shootings and many murders: mental illness.

Hamilton County Sheriff Jim Hammond frequently discusses the overwhelming number of mentally ill prisoners in our jails because there are no other facilities in which to detain them. The dilemma begs the question: How do we ensure the public is protected from mentally ill citizens who might do harm?

To answer that question, I sought the help of Dr. Larry Thompson. He has spent his entire adult life working in various capacities within mental illness care across Tennessee.