Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

State calls eyewitnesses in 2016 Labor Day weekend double homicide trial

Stephen Mobley, 34, sits left of defense attorney Eliza Williams Tuesday in Judge Barry Steelman's courtroom during jury selection.
Stephen Mobley, 34, sits left of defense attorney Eliza Williams Tuesday in Judge Barry Steelman's courtroom during jury selection.
photo Stephen Mobley, 34, walks in to Judge Barry Steelman’s courtroom during jury selection on Tuesday.

A Chattanooga man committed double homicide in 2016 because he felt disrespected during an evening of partying, prosecutors argued Wednesday. But getting some eyewitnesses to say that on Stephen Mobley’s opening day of trial proved more challenging.

Mobley is accused of fatally shooting Jasmine Hines, 22, and Rashaud Taylor, 23, and injuring Zirrshaddia Scott, after an argument broke out about cleaning vomit during a night of partying at a home on Pinewood Drive on Sept. 5, 2016. Mobley was one of a handful of people gathered at the home for a Labor Day weekend cookout-turned-party that involved marijuana, alcohol and Xanax.

He has pleaded not guilty to his charges of first-degree murder, attempted first-degree murder, aggravated assault and employing a firearm during a dangerous felony.

Using eyewitnesses, prosecutors say Mobley displayed a gun that night and was one of the last people inside before nearly 10 rounds went off. After the shooting, one person who also lived on Pinewood Drive and left the party earlier initially told authorities he saw Mobley outside on the street.

But that witness, Jeremy Cotton, said he couldn’t recall it Wednesday.