Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Court vacates Marion County bail bonding firm’s suspension over ‘sextortion’

Kelvin Pell
Kelvin Pell

Tennessee appeals court judges have vacated a six-month suspension handed to a regional bail bonding company after one of its former contractors was caught seeking sex in in return for writing a woman’s bond.

The Tennessee Court of Appeals said judges in Marion County was wrong to punish Cumberland Bail Bonding, its owner, and two other bonding companies he owns in the county over misconduct by ex-bondsman Kelvin Pell.

photo Kelvin Pell

In an opinion published Wednesday, the appeals court judges said Pell’s behavior was “shocking to the conscience,” but said there was no evidence that his employer knew about it, was negligent in its hiring practices or failed to immediately remove him as soon as it became public.

Cumberland Bail Bonding owner Andy Baggenstoss said he feels “vindicated” by the appeals court ruling.

“First and foremost, we would want to say we deeply regret [Pell’s] actions were harmful to someone, and this is not indicative or the standard in which I run any of my companies,” Baggenstoss said.