Skip to main content
Friday, November 13, 2026Nov 13

Tennessee man heads back to prison, says goodbye to new life

In this April 28, 2018, photo, Matthew Charles walks into a surprise gathering of friends and coworkers in his honor just weeks before his release, in Nashville, Tenn. (Julieta Martinelli/Nashville Public Radio via AP)
In this April 28, 2018, photo, Matthew Charles walks into a surprise gathering of friends and coworkers in his honor just weeks before his release, in Nashville, Tenn. (Julieta Martinelli/Nashville Public Radio via AP) In this April 28, 2018, photo, Matthew Charles walks into a surprise gathering of friends and coworkers in his honor just weeks before his release, in Nashville, Tenn. (Julieta Martinelli/Nashville Public Radio via AP)

NASHVILLE, Tenn. (AP) – When a Nashville man named Matthew Charles was released from prison early in 2016 after a sentence reduction, he’d spent almost half his life behind bars. But in a rare move, a federal court ruled his term was reduced in error and ordered him back behind bars to finish his sentence.

It’s 4 o’clock on a Saturday in late April, and over a dozen people have gathered for a surprise party in honor of Matthew Charles at his girlfriend Naomi Tharpe’s home.

Charles is a little late, which is good, because guests are still making their way in through a side door when a friend who’s been entertaining him sends Tharpe a text announcing their arrival.

The guests – an assorted bunch including members of his church congregation, coworkers, volunteers from a local food pantry and even a former cellmate – are bursting with laughter. Tharpe has just passed out tiny, colorful water guns so they can spray Charles.

photo In this April 28, 2018, photo, Matthew Charles greets his friend John Hairston, who flew in from Houston to surprise him, in Nashville, Tenn. (Vince Hill/Nashville Public Radio)

A hush passes over the crowd as they spot him approaching through the narrow slats of the tall wooden gate.