While awaiting a judge’s final order in a civil nuisance case that aims to keep 31 alleged gang members from associating with each other in East Lake Courts, a defense attorney has filed another motion calling for the state’s main piece of evidence to be thrown out.
In a June 19 motion filed in Hamilton County Criminal Court, attorney Chrissy Mincy said prosecutors shouldn’t be able to enter gang validation forms as evidence under a “business exception rule” because the information contained within them is secondhand, outdated and unverified.
“This [business rule] is the only exception cited by the District Attorney General,” Mincy wrote. “However, this exception does not apply for a multitude of reasons.”
Validation forms are what the Chattanooga Police Department uses to categorize someone as a gang member. Officers use a points system to “validate” someone, and each criteria, be it tattoos, confessions, social media posts, or being spotted with other gang members, has a different value. For example, admitting you’re a gang member to an officer carries nine points. A person needs only 10 points to be validated as a member, and anything less means you can be “associated” with the gang.
Since he filed his case in September 2016 against the 31 men, who allegedly belong to the Grape Street Crips and Gangster Disciples, Hamilton County District Attorney General Neal Pinkston has relied on those forms. He entered them as evidence during a hearing in 2016 and used them during a hearing in April to determine whether a permanent version of his petition should be put into effect.
