Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Attorneys ask Tennessee’s top court to restore confidence in DUI enforcement

In this 2015 staff file photo, a sign comparing the costs of a taxi ride and a DUI conviction is seen on the back window of a Tennessee Highway Patrol vehicle painted to resemble a taxi during a news conference with members of the Chattanooga Police Department, Hamilton County Sheriff's Office and Georgia State Patrol in Chattanooga, Tenn., discussing DUI enforcement efforts during the holiday season.
In this 2015 staff file photo, a sign comparing the costs of a taxi ride and a DUI conviction is seen on the back window of a Tennessee Highway Patrol vehicle painted to resemble a taxi during a news conference with members of the Chattanooga Police Department, Hamilton County Sheriff's Office and Georgia State Patrol in Chattanooga, Tenn., discussing DUI enforcement efforts during the holiday season.

Tennessee’s top attorneys want the highest state court to restore public confidence in DUI enforcement by reversing a recent court ruling that left hundreds of impaired driving cases in Chattanooga and beyond in limbo.

In a filing Wednesday, Assistant Solicitor General Jonathan Shaub disagreed with last month’s ruling from the Criminal Court of Appeals that said the Tennessee Bureau of Investigation was overseeing an “unconstitutional” fee system that only required defendants to pay a $250 blood test fee upon their conviction.

Because of that ruling, which stems from a 2012 DUI case in Chattanooga, many attorneys believe Tennessee courts can’t allow crucial blood or breath testing into evidence in impaired driving cases as long as TBI’s crime lab continues to receive the fee. They say the fee creates the “appearance of impropriety” and brings test results into question.

But the ruling has also brought DUI prosecutions to a grinding halt, which is why Shaub wants the Tennessee Supreme Court to “resolve this turmoil” before the ruling affects past convictions, too.

“In the aftermath of the decision, prosecutors across the state have reported constitutional challenges to the state’s use of [blood and breath] testing as evidence,” Shaub wrote. “Several prosecutions have simply been put on hold.