Skip to main content
Sunday, November 15, 2026Nov 15

Jurors find Chattanooga man not guilty in fatal 2016 bar brawl

William Harvey
William Harvey

After a two-day trial, jurors found a Chattanooga man “not guilty” in a fatal 2016 bar brawl.

Chattanooga prosecutors said William “Matt” Harvey, 27, used unnecessary force when he stabbed Shawn Russell, 36, near the heart on April 5, 2016, during a fight at Rumors Bar in Hixson.

photo William Harvey

But Harvey said he stabbed Russell once with a 3-inch knife to stop him from beating a third man, Johnathan Harvey, to death.

On the witness stand, Harvey said nobody tried to stop Russell as he swung a pool cue into Johnathan Harvey’s face, jumped on top of his body and punched him several times in the face around 1 a.m.

According to trial testimony, Johnathan Harvey nearly provoked Russell into a fight earlier that evening. When Johnathan Harvey then said something about Russell’s girlfriend, Russell unscrewed a pool stick, walked across the bar with the two pieces behind his back, and began to attack Johnathan Harvey, according to testimony.