Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Discrimination trial: Accused Hamilton County judge denies firing employee for being gay

Former Juvenile Court magistrate Elizabeth Gentzler, left, leaves the Joel W. Solomon Federal Courthouse with her wife Jennifer during a trial recess on Thursday, March 22, 2018, in Chattanooga, Tenn. Testimony continued Thursday in Gentzler's federal lawsuit against Hamilton County, Juvenile Court Judge Rob Philyaw and administrator Sam Mairs which claims Gentzler was discriminated against and fired in 2014 for being gay.
Former Juvenile Court magistrate Elizabeth Gentzler, left, leaves the Joel W. Solomon Federal Courthouse with her wife Jennifer during a trial recess on Thursday, March 22, 2018, in Chattanooga, Tenn. Testimony continued Thursday in Gentzler's federal lawsuit against Hamilton County, Juvenile Court Judge Rob Philyaw and administrator Sam Mairs which claims Gentzler was discriminated against and fired in 2014 for being gay.

A Hamilton County judge being sued for discrimination denied firing one of his employees in 2014 for being openly gay and pointed Thursday to her confrontational behavior.

Juvenile Court Judge Rob Philyaw said he never gave Elizabeth Gentzler, 38, a reason for firing her in 2014, explaining that he wanted to avoid “unnecessary confrontation” because he believed she would argue with him. On the stand Thursday in Gentzler’s $500,000 civil discrimination trial against him, Hamilton County and another key member of Juvenile Court, Philyaw said her court “had risen to a level of complete inappropriateness.”

Pressed for examples, Philyaw said he heard complaints of too much laughter in Gentzler’s courtroom between hearings. Philyaw said the former magistrate also used profanity on one occasion but he couldn’t recall who told him that. Philyaw said the behavior made him think Gentzler had been prematurely appointed to the position of magistrate in 2011. He transferred her to a different division of Juvenile Court in January 2014 and fired her that August on the phone without explanation.

photo Juvenile Court Judge Rob Philyaw, left, and Hamilton County Attorney Rheubin Taylor, right, leave the Joel W. Solomon Federal Courthouse during a trial recess on Thursday, March 22, 2018, in Chattanooga, Tenn. Testimony continued Thursday in Elizabeth Gentzler’s federal lawsuit against Hamilton County, Judge Philyaw and administrator Sam Mairs which claims Gentzler was discriminated against and fired in 2014 for being gay.

Gentzler’s attorney, James Stuart, said those claims didn’t make any sense because Gentzler’s work was respected in Juvenile Court. If there were actually issues, why didn’t Philyaw say, “‘Ms. Gentzler, don’t do that?'” James asked.

“I did at the Tuesday morning meetings,” Philyaw replied.