Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Cleaveland: Shouldn’t voters have a say in health care legislation?

The SafeSEAL(TM) antimicrobial soft diaphram slips onto any stethoscope effortlessly. Changed only once a week, SafeSEAL(TM)  helps provide protection against harmful bacteria commonly found on stethoscopes. Available in adult, pediatric and infant sizes. (PRNewsFoto)
The SafeSEAL(TM) antimicrobial soft diaphram slips onto any stethoscope effortlessly. Changed only once a week, SafeSEAL(TM) helps provide protection against harmful bacteria commonly found on stethoscopes. Available in adult, pediatric and infant sizes. (PRNewsFoto)
photo Dr. Clif Cleaveland

Earlier this year, Tennessee Attorney General Herbert Slatery III joined 18 other state AGs in support of a suit filed in a Texas federal district court to invalidate the Affordable Care Act.

The tax legislation passed by Congress in December 2017 abolished the penalty for individuals who chose not to purchase health insurance – the so-called individual mandate. The repeal of this penalty takes effect in January 2019. Plaintiffs in the Texas suit argue that invalidation of one part of the Affordable Care Act makes the entire ACA unconstitutional. The court began hearing oral arguments in the case on Sept. 10.

Forty-three states elect their AGs. Governors or legislatures appoint six AGs. Tennessee is unique in having the state Supreme Court select the AG for a term of eight years. AG Slatery began his term in 2016.

Tennessee’s AG serves as the chief law enforcement officer for the state as well as counselor and adviser for all components of state government. The AG’s duties are outlined in the State Code, Title 8, Chapter 6, Section 109.

Voiding the ACA without replacement legislation ready to take effect would lead to chaos in U.S. health care. The requirement that people with pre-existing conditions must have access to health insurance without penalty would be voided. Expansion of Medicaid programs, which 32 states and the District of Columbia undertook, would be nullified. Inclusion in insurance plans of essential health benefits, such as mental health care, cancer screenings and vaccinations, would be eliminated.