Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Contradicting police statement, witness testifies she didn’t see killer in Rising Fawn homicide

RISING FAWN, Ga. – One of the witnesses in a December killing says she did not actually see Samuel Alfred Street pull the trigger, contradicting what she supposedly told police hours after the shooting.

“This is the first time I’ve seen Sam Street in 20 years,” Kristy Hatfield testified during a preliminary hearing in Dade County Magistrate Court on Jan. 17. “I mean, face to face, you know?”

Her statement contradicts that of Dade County Deputy Nathan Sledge, who reported to the scene of the shooting at 106 Highway 11 South around 12:30 a.m. on Dec. 15. Sledge said he interviewed Hatfield and Justin Keith, the only other known witness to the shooting. At the time, Sledge said, there didn’t seem to be any question about who pulled the trigger.

“I asked Ms. Hatfield and Mr. Keith if they recognized who was at the driveway [at the time of the shooting],” Sledge recalled during the hearing last week. “And they both mentioned Sambo Street, which I later learned was Sam Street.”

Hatfield said the interview was recorded, evidence that Street’s attorneys have not yet received.