College football playoff rankings
OK, the SEC had three of the top five teams in the poll released Tuesday night by the 13-person college football playoff committee. Here are the details from TFP college football wizard David Paschall.
In the grand scheme of things, that and $4 will get you a Starbucks Venti caramel organic half-and-half latte thingy. Maybe.
Everyone needs to go full-blown Aaron Rodgers on these rankings.
The curious spot about the second round of these rankings, though, is the continued happenstance of critical thinking.
We all expected LSU to jump to No. 1 and the Tigers did.
But LSU’s résumé was better than THE Ohio State’s before the first poll, too, and the Tigers were No. 2.
(Side point: Thanks to the tireless work of handicapper and gambling-writing guru Brian Edwards – follow him @vegasbedwards on Twitter – here are his best guesses on the top five and the numbers Vegas would assess. Enjoy. “I usually say ‘neutral tomorrow,’ but let’s call this neutral 2 weeks & thus, Tua 90% healthy. LSU -3 vs Clemson; Clemson -1.5 vs Bama; LSU -4 vs Ohio St.; LSU -8.5 vs UGA; Bama -1 vs OSU; Bama -6.5 vs UGA; Ohio St. -6 vs. UGA; Clemson -2 vs OSU; Clemson -7 vs UGA.” So there’s that.)
The top three were to be expected, I suppose.
LSU, THE OSU and a Clemson team that has shifted gears and been drumming people since the scare in Chapel Hill.
Small surprise that Georgia jumped Alabama for the No. 4 spot. Not sure if that is an overarching message in scheduling – good wins > bad losses – or a calculated placement because Alabama is the highest ranked team that must have help to make it into the playoff.
(Here’s a weekly announcement, that yes, we’re certain we have used it in the past, but the phrase “controlling their own destiny” is nonsensical because destiny is predetermined and out of everyone’s control. That is all.)
To that point, ranking the teams with the most direct control of their postseason plans, let’s review:
1. LSU. Control: 100 percent. Simple. Win out and the Tigers are no worse than the 2 seed, and most likely with that schedule, the 1 in Atlanta.
2. THE Ohio State: Control: 100 percent. Simple. Read the above.
3. Clemson. Control: 100 percent. But the stakes are higher for Dabo’s Tigers, because unlike the two teams listed above, Clemson has absolutely zero margin for error, whereas there are scenarios that LSU and THE Ohio State have room for a mulligan.
4. Georgia. Control: 100 percent. And we believed that before the Dawgs moved to 4 Tuesday night. If Georgia wins at Auburn and then beats LSU on a neutral field, no one’s keeping the Bulldogs from the field.
5. Minnesota. Control: 100 percent. Yes, 100 percent. Unlike Baylor, which still could be on the outside looking in as an undefeated Power 5 conference champ – which is a staggering statement – if the Gophers win out, which would mean beating THE OSU, PJ Fleck can row his boat in the field of four.
Everyone after that actually needs help. Those are the five that can look in the mirror and know that handling their BID-ness means Bidness into the dance.
Yes, considering that the SEC and the Big Ten have overlapping conflicts on the horizon, the open spot is not automatic for an unbeaten Baylor, a one-loss Oklahoma or a one-loss Pac-12 champ like Oregon or Utah.
How, you ask?
Pretty simply, let’s say the Georgia scenario unfolds and they beat LSU – which has been the most accomplished team all year with four top-10 wins already – LSU would have strong support over the Baylor-OU winner or the Pac-12 champ.
And, no matter how much we are worried about expanded playoffs watering down the best regular season in sports, well, the images of an unbeaten Power 5 conference champ on the outside looking in will expedite the expansion of the field.
