Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

5-at-10: Friday mailbag on best NFL draft pick ever, huge expectations for ‘The Last Dance’ and a fake news diatribe

Jay Greeson / Staff file photo
Jay Greeson / Staff file photo

From Matt H.

I have been reading your blog a while now and have noticed a few rules. Have you ever published a list of said rules?

Also, I have a hunch that you like the draft. Is Brady the best draft pick ever? Thanks and keep up the great work.

Matt –

An actual set of rules? Don’t know that we’ve ever collected a formal collection of by-laws.

There are a few that are understood, though. When Paschall writes about college football – like he did today on Nick Tiano – we link it. Same with Weeds on college hoops.

When we reference UK – especially hoops – we add a reference to Chas. We add a regular Spy reference, normally around thinking, because to my knowledge, those are the longest-standing regulars who occupied these circles almost from the very start, back when we thought a paywall was the front side of a toll booth.

We have developed a regular rotation of contests – NCAA tournament, Masters, NFL Draft, Kentucky Derby and the College Bowl contest are longstanding features. (We will have the NFL draft contest, with details coming next week.)

I try to mix and mingle as many recognizable movie quotes as possible.

Some of the regular tools – side notes and side questions chief among them – are more about writing style than set structure. And by that I mean, my writing style by design is conversational. I try to make my columns have a similar rhythm to how we would be speaking if we were discussing the topics in my writing.

I appreciate the question, and if I’ve forgotten anything – a very real possibility – feel free to offer it up.

As for your alleged “hunch,” well, sir, I don’t “like” the draft. I love the draft; you should know this.

No, I don’t think Tom Brady is the greatest draft pick ever. He’s the luckiest draft pick of all time. The return on investment – six Super Bowl rings from pick 199 – is staggering.

It would have been a great pick if the Pats had actually taken him earlier, but Brady was more winning the lottery than working the system. Is that splitting hairs? Maybe.

But not unlike how JaMarcus Russell is the biggest draft bust ever because of who was picked in the slots after him, there has to be some cleverness and craft into the greatest pick ever.

For instance, trading up to get Julio Jones or even Patrick Mahomes a couple of years ago are better actual draft day moves than the Patriots throwing a dart at Ann Arbor and striking gold.

Still, it’s an amazingly tough question, though, but I would lean toward the 49ers taking Jerry Rice from Mississippi Valley State in round 1 with the 16th pick – it was acquired from the Pats, actually – as the best pick ever.

From Kirk

Great read, how much hell do you catch when you throw in small jabs at elected officials? I agree with the statement just curious.

Kirk –

I assume you’re referring to the “Trump-level narcissism” line from earlier this week.

And the answer is normally, and it’s never been more vitriolic than right now.

It also has never been more divided, especially when President Trump’s name is mentioned.

If it’s something positive about the president, I’m a bleeping apologist. If it’s something negative, I’m in the liberal media.

And that’s the thinking that has left us all in a loss.

To that end, phrases such as fake news and media bias are so detrimental to way more parts of society than most know. (Side note here: Why are the airlines and other industries clamoring for buyouts and bailouts when the media world has been hemorrhaging jobs for two decades? There’s no reference to the flying industry in the Bill of Rights, friends.)

As for the views on those in my position, well, I’ve got a pretty thick skin. You guys have seen my hate mail. I get it, and I can take it.

But here’s a little background especially for me: Of course I am biased. That’s my job. I write my opinion eight times a week – five here, three times a week on A2. Read that again.

It’s my opinion, which is shaped by my thoughts, my beliefs and, yes, my bias.

But to fulfill the actual “Media Bias” it would have been calculated and directed from higher levels, right? And having sat in on thousands of news meetings and story brainstorming sessions through the years, I have never had a boss say, “Hey, you have to write this.”

Sure, the CNN and Fox News money grab to preach to their audiences does the entire journalism industry no favors. I understand the thought process of going for the money grab and making a profit. They are a BID-ness, after all.

But it doesn’t mean I have to like it. Because I loathe it, and it has forever damaged a profession I love.

As for the “Fake News” laments, well, when media members make mistakes, well, we all pay for them in the all-important currencies of trust and credibility.

But the folks who use that banner to blame the messenger because they don’t like the message are weak and part of the divide problem we face as a nation.

Specifically, I got this email from the Trump reference to narcissism: “You just pretend to like Trump and your insults like saying he’s narcissistic – did you have to look that word up? – will not stop him from saving America. I’ll be glad when the paper fires you.”

OK, whatever. So it goes.

But a) is it wrong to say Trump is narcissistic and b) is it truly an insult? No to both. Not by the definition of the word and the course of Trump’s actions. Heck, here’s betting his family discusses his narcissism.

But it’s a sign of the times, and thanks Kirk for reading.