Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Mallen: On reopening, leaders must choose the best wrong answer amid COVID-19 crisis

Photo by Mark Humphrey of The Associated Press / Tennessee Gov. Bill Lee visits a drive-through COVID-19 testing location on Saturday, April 18, 2020, in Franklin, Tennessee. An expanded testing effort launched in Tennessee Saturday includes workers from the Tennessee National Guard at 15 drive-through testing sites across the state.
Photo by Mark Humphrey of The Associated Press / Tennessee Gov. Bill Lee visits a drive-through COVID-19 testing location on Saturday, April 18, 2020, in Franklin, Tennessee. An expanded testing effort launched in Tennessee Saturday includes workers from the Tennessee National Guard at 15 drive-through testing sites across the state.

Before COVID-19, we all played tag on an elementary school playground or maybe dodgeball in the gym. “Tag, you’re it,” until you touched the next victim, or a pop of the ball as it ricocheted off of two or three other classmates. It was fun and exciting! A game at recess and a chance to have fun. If we played outside, the games were harder. More room to run around. If we played in the gym, the play area was more confined. The physical environment impacted the play site exposure risk (more on that later).

Horse racing fans, think of the Kentucky Derby, both 30 seconds before the race begins and 30 seconds after. Before the starting gates open, the horses and jockeys are separated. The jockeys are in sparkling racing silks; their horses clean and eager to run. After the bell, there is chaos, contact and shared dirt, mud and sweat. Cleanliness and distancing degrade to cross-contamination in an instant.

Full disclosure and a couple of facts: I have practiced environmental, health and safety, and related catastrophic response law for 32 years. This experience has enabled me to work with and to learn from some of the brightest and most talented OSHA, EPA and private-sector scientists, investigators and regulators in the business.

I think I know what they are thinking as this pandemic unfolds – not politically, but rather in terms of managing a crisis that has no perfect playbook. We are learning on the fly. No standard operating procedures for this one. Catastrophic response happens that way. They are relying on environmental health and safety rule number one: Workplace site conditions must be managed to prevent employee and visitor exposures to hazards which may result in serious injury or death.

We do not know the right answer. So in order to lead, we must have the courage to pick the best wrong answer, and then lead, follow or get out of the way.