Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Broughel: Joe Biden’s looming legitimacy crisis (and what he can do about it)

Photo by Calla Kessler of The New York Times / Former Secretary of State John Kerry, showm here with Joe Biden aboard Biden's campaign bus during his "No Malarkey" bus tour in Elkader, Iowa, on Friday, Dec. 6, 2019. Biden, as president-elect, named Kerry to be envoy for climate.
Photo by Calla Kessler of The New York Times / Former Secretary of State John Kerry, showm here with Joe Biden aboard Biden's campaign bus during his "No Malarkey" bus tour in Elkader, Iowa, on Friday, Dec. 6, 2019. Biden, as president-elect, named Kerry to be envoy for climate.

As a wild 2020 rolls into 2021, President-elect Joe Biden sits in a precarious position. Even as the Trump campaign’s election challenges strike out, millions of voters question Biden’s legitimacy. He promised to unite a divided country, and now he has to find a way to deliver.

It would be best for Biden – and for the country – to take a cooperative rather than a combative approach. With true bipartisan leadership, there is a surprising amount that might be accomplished even with a Democrat-led House and what’s likely to be a Republican Senate (pending the two runoff elections in Georgia). Immigration, entitlements, deficit reduction and regulations are a few areas where this division of power could allow the stars to align for reform.

In one of his first speeches after the media called the election, Biden promised to be a unifying president who will not exacerbate our divisions. While most Americans, this author included, are willing to believe him, he will rapidly lose goodwill if he follows his party’s leftmost flank.

Sen. Elizabeth Warren has called on Biden to take an aggressive pen-and-phone strategy out of the Obama playbook, meaning to pursue extensive use of executive actions. This would allow him to bypass what could be a gridlocked Congress. On the other hand, it will almost certainly antagonize Republicans and centrists, and increase the likelihood that Biden is viewed as an illegitimate president – one abusing the tepid trust he earned from a weary American public.

The last election may have been a rejection of Donald Trump’s fiery brand of politics, but many observers note that it was also a rejection of far-left policies, due to the many successes of Republicans down ticket. Thus, the president-elect’s real mandate is to pursue the types of reforms that all but the most partisan among us support.