In March, when fears about the dearth of medical grade masks for health care professionals were dominating social media discussions, I asked my friend – a physician’s assistant in a big East Coast hospital emergency department – if I should put my paltry sewing skills to work making cloth face coverings.
“I appreciate your enthusiasm,” she replied, “but we’ll all end up with COVID-19 if we wear cloth masks.”
She directed me to a study from 2015 in which researchers tested surgical and cloth masks in clinical settings involving high-risk exposure to respiratory infections in Vietnam. Cloth masks, they found, not only resulted in higher rates of infection than surgical masks but also showed higher rates of infection than the control group (which followed standard hospital procedures, including use of surgical, cloth or no masks at all).
It would have made sense if this type of finding was what motivated the surgeon general in February, to tweet, that masks “are NOT effective in preventing general public from catching #Coronavirus”; Health and Human Services Secretary Alex Azar to suggest that improper mask use could actually spread the virus; and Dr. Anthony Fauci to confidently declare on 60 Minutes, that a mask is not “the perfect protection that people think that it is.”
But it wasn’t.
