Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Goldberg: Despite author’s claims, there’s no defense for looting

The Associated Press / Police take control of the streets after making arrests during one of the nights of protests, riots and looting in Portland, Oregon, last month.
The Associated Press / Police take control of the streets after making arrests during one of the nights of protests, riots and looting in Portland, Oregon, last month.

Vicky Osterweil, the author of “In Defense of Looting: A Riotous History of Uncivil Action,” is getting her 15 minutes of fame thanks to a segment on NPR in which she said some really mind-bogglingly dumb, indefensibly evil and fascinatingly reactionary things.

We’ll come back to her in a moment.

One of my weird mental pastimes is to look at the world as if I were a visitor from the past. But rather than think of how a time traveler might marvel at the new technology and tall buildings, I like to wonder: What would someone from 500 or 1,000 years ago recognize as familiar?

Some things are obvious: a mother breastfeeding a baby or an old man tending a garden. “We do that too!” a time traveler might say on first sight.

But if you were a sophisticated and knowledgeable time traveler, you might recognize some deeper similarities.