Hall of Shame
What a farce Cooperstown has become.
It’s hard to even take it seriously, if we’re being honest.
Between the efforts of the Veterans Committee to make it the Hall of Good to the hypocrisy of the voting writers, what once was a bucket list trip for me and my kids is forever tarnished. A hollow, self-serving tree house club that now falls somewhere between Branson, Mo., and the world’s biggest ball of yarn on my traveling to-do list.
Let’s review: David Ortiz, who was documented as being found to be a performance-enhancing drugs user in the Mitchell Report, gets in on the first ballot. Roger Clemens and Barry Bonds were denied again in their 10th and final time on the ballot.
First, let’s get to Ortiz. Is he a Hall of Famer? Yes. And no.
Yes, in the sense of the current climate that has allowed Alan Trammell, Ted Simmons and Harold Baines in recently. Side note: Those three dudes combined for 817 homers, 20 All-Star appearances, four Gold Gloves, five Silver Sluggers and one – ONE – top-five appearance in the MVP voting. (Trammell was runner-up in 1987.) That’s combined from three dudes who somehow were viewed as Hall of Fame worthy. Bonds has 762 homers, 14 All-Star trips, eight Gold Gloves, two batting titles, 12 Silver Sluggers and seven – SEVEN – MVPs. Whatever. And seriously, can you be a serious candidate for the Hall of Fame if you were never a top-five finisher for the MVP? I don’t think so.
The stats around Bonds are mind-blowing, and I loved this one that circulated Tuesday evening. David Ortiz’ career on-base percentage was .380; if you turned all 762 of Bonds’ homers into outs, his career OBP would have been .382.
Speaking of Ortiz, who said at one time that his leaked failed PED test was because of New York bias, which proves bias can be used as an excuse/deflection of anything. His 541 homers and his postseason excellence make him a Hall of Fame candidate for sure.
But if the hall was what it should be, he would be a strong contender, not a lead-pipe cinch, with or without the failed PED test.
And while the eye test and the common knowledge test – Roger Clemens was consistently dinged because he was doing stuff into his 40s that he was doing in his early 20s. Which makes him a lot like Nolan Ryan, but we all loved Nolan, so let’s not talk about that.
And we all love Big Papi, because all his numbers, his cuddly disposition and his passion for the game pushed him over the top in the voting.
And that’s junk.
And this is where the eye test and common knowledge about PEDs should be weighed again. Yes, Bonds’ body transformed over the years, but the dude was amazing even at 170 pounds in Pittsburgh.
Big Papi was a fringe big leaguer before heading to Boston in 2003 – the year he failed the PED test. In his six years in Minnesota, Ortiz bounced between the majors and minors, hitting .266 – as a DH mind you – with 58 homers and 238 RBIs. That’s six years’ worth of work. That’s a season and a half for Bonds, who never failed a PED test, leaked or otherwise.
Then he heads to Boston – and reportedly failed a PED test and he becomes a cross between Ted Williams and Willie Stargell. Hmmmmmmm.
What a sham. And a shame.
Anyone got directions for the best way to Branson?
