Skip to main content
Saturday, November 14, 2026Nov 14

Opinion: We are political hostages

File photo by Luke Sharrett of The New York Times / A voter leaves a polling pace in Simpsonville, Ky., on June 23, 2022. "One of our greatest errors as a country has been our nonstop campaign to convince generations of voters that elections are about freedom of choice," New York Times columnist Charles M. Blow writes.
File photo by Luke Sharrett of The New York Times / A voter leaves a polling pace in Simpsonville, Ky., on June 23, 2022. "One of our greatest errors as a country has been our nonstop campaign to convince generations of voters that elections are about freedom of choice," New York Times columnist Charles M. Blow writes.

One of our greatest errors as a country has been our nonstop campaign to convince generations of voters that elections are about freedom of choice.

This may be true if you are of a class not historically oppressed by the state. Many white people, particularly white men, fall into this category. They have the ability – the power – to be swing voters, knowing that their basic civil rights are not on the line.

In November 2019, Nate Cohn in The New York Times analyzed a number of surveys of swing-state voters and looked specifically at the “persuadable pool,” the 15% of voters in the battleground states who were undecided and still thinking of voting for Donald Trump or a Democrat.

He found, “As a group they are 57% male and 72% white.”

For most other people, “freedom of choice” in elections is an illusion. We are captives of the two-party system. We are political hostages.