Skip to main content
Tuesday, November 17, 2026Nov 17

Opinion: What’s worse than an ‘F’? Supreme Court showed us with abortion ruling

File photo by Christopher Lee of The New York Times / The Supreme Court in Washington is shown in August 2020.
File photo by Christopher Lee of The New York Times / The Supreme Court in Washington is shown in August 2020.

We can’t even imagine a grade adequate for the Supreme Court this year, as the current scale stops after only five letters. If we ever wondered how to get a worse grade than “F,” the U.S. Supreme Court showed us when they overturned abortion rights.

The Supreme Court’s ruling in Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health obliterated the landscape around the Supreme Court. It devastated the court’s legitimacy and solidified its growing reputation as a political instrument that is free to be used to advance an extremist, partisan agenda.

While this case was not the only SCOTUS ruling to set back women’s rights – the New York gun decision comes to mind – it didn’t appear out of a vacuum. The Supreme Court has been earning its failing grade for a long time.

Days before the Dobbs decision, public confidence in the court was at an all-time low, with only a 25% approval rating from Gallup. It’s no wonder – in case after case, the court has sided with those who would restrict, repeal and deny our rights, and do nothing to advance autonomy and equality.

The court’s ruling to end the constitutional right to abortion could mean the death penalty for more pregnant women of color than ever, including Black, Indigenous and Latino people. These groups have long been systematically disadvantaged and neglected by the health care system, which is pervaded by racism, discrimination and marginalization.