Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Opinion: Can polls survive losing half the country?

Attacking the credibility of polls (and pollsters) has become a kind of bank shot for those aiming to destroy the credibility of the institution that polls simulate: elections. Among MAGA adherents, if the polls are off, it’s not because polling has become more difficult. It’s because everything is corrupt and nothing is true.

The political science department of Vanderbilt University has said that pre-election polls in 2020 exhibited the “largest errors in 40 years.” That mistake hovers over the 2022 election and influences the work, and reputations, of the partisans and pollsters (and partisan pollsters) who are trying to gauge the trajectory of a large, diverse and unruly electorate.

One partisan who has staked out a clear patch of terrain in this debate is Simon Rosenberg, a longtime Democratic consultant. Rosenberg is a particular kind of political player, both partisan and credible. While he wants Democrats to win, he also values his reputation as an astute analyst of American politics; he wants to be right.

At a time when there is growing discussion of a red wave — “Democrats Prepare for Loss of Congress as Voters Break Late to GOP” reads a recent headline — Rosenberg has been making the case that Democrats might still buck history and retain control of Congress. “I think the election now is very close and it is unknowable what’s going to happen,” Rosenberg told me. “The polling can’t get down to a level of granular detail when elections are this close.”

His bet is that much of the anti-Trump coalition of 2018 and 2020 will reconstitute itself as an anti-MAGA force, having correctly gauged that the stakes of this election are immense.