Most retention votes for Tennessee Supreme Court justices come and go with little fanfare. In the end, through the years, voters almost always return incumbent judges to the bench.
When former Justice William M. “Mickey” Barker of Signal Mountain, who died in Chattanooga Monday, was up for retention for the first time in 1998, those with whom he associated just couldn’t help themselves. They wanted to praise the Chattanooga native this page once termed an appropriate choice for the high court because of his “personal integrity, intelligence, dedication, good judgment and faithfulness to the Constitution and law.”
“He is among the very best judges I have seen in the 65 years I have practiced law; intelligent, kind, articulate, considerate, and learned in the law,” wrote Jac Chambliss, before his appointment.
That was but one among many.
Then-Tennessee Gov. Don Sundquist made Barker his first judicial appointment as governor in 1994, elevating him from the Circuit Court for the 11th District to the state Court of Criminal Appeals, and then to the Supreme Court in 1998. He became chief justice in 2005.
