Gun politics in the U.S. demonstrates that a popular majority does not always get its way. Even though most Americans support stricter gun-safety laws, proposals for major new regulations reliably face impassable obstacles in Congress.
The standard explanation for this impasse is that the minority is highly mobilized and well-funded. This is only half right: The power of gun-control opponents stems more from their shared sense of identity than from their money.
Democratic leaders habitually accuse the National Rifle Association of buying the votes of Republican politicians via direct financial contributions and independent campaign expenditures.
But while the NRA is a famously powerful interest group — despite some serious recent management problems — most of its influence does not derive from the money it spends on elections. As the political scientist Matthew Lacombe explains in his 2021 book “Firepower,” the NRA’s most transformational achievement was not financial but cultural: It successfully defined gun ownership as a distinctive form of social identity.
For decades, Lacombe writes, the NRA has encouraged gun owners to see themselves as “reputable, honest, patriotic citizens who are self-sufficient and love freedom” but who constantly face unmerited attacks from “politicians, the media and lawyers.” He concludes that gun-control supporters are at a relative disadvantage because they lack a countervailing identity of their own.
