Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Opinion: Kevin McCarthy’s success comes at a price

Photo/Jose Luis Magana/The Associated Press / Speaker of the House Kevin McCarthy, R-Calif., walks inside the Capitol in Washington on Thursday, April 27, 2023. House Republicans have narrowly passed a sweeping debt ceiling package as they try to push President Biden into negotiations on federal spending.
Photo/Jose Luis Magana/The Associated Press / Speaker of the House Kevin McCarthy, R-Calif., walks inside the Capitol in Washington on Thursday, April 27, 2023. House Republicans have narrowly passed a sweeping debt ceiling package as they try to push President Biden into negotiations on federal spending.

Speaker Kevin McCarthy scored a big win with the passage of a Republican debt-limit proposal stocked with spending cuts and other rollbacks to Democratic priorities. While the measure has no chance of winning support of Senate Democrats or President Joe Biden, it sets up a period of fierce confrontation between the two parties.

Until this week, we appeared headed for a different outcome. After the chaos of the speaker election in January, it seemed possible that House Republicans, given their narrow House majority, would realize that anything that would eventually pass into law would need a bipartisan coalition of the center against the ideological fringes.

It was also possible that we would witness more chaos, with the House proving ungovernable, McCarthy’s job constantly in danger and more failed votes on the House floor.

But somewhat surprisingly, McCarthy managed to foster a consensus with both moderate and far-right Republicans, at least around this one bill that everyone knew was more about messaging than realistic policy. It’s a trajectory that promises maximum conflict with President Joe Biden and the Democratic Senate.

The vote not only raises the chance of a debt-limit breach and financial panic; it also means that we’re on the way to a series of hostage-taking episodes, with the chances of a government shutdown in the fall also growing, and the promise, if the GOP extremists get their way, of another debt-limit showdown in less than a year.