Our nation’s highest court — the Supreme Court — should live by the highest ethical standards. Right now, no transparent code of conduct governs its nine members like there is for all other federal judges — one that requires judges to “avoid impropriety and the appearance of impropriety in all activities.” It is long past time for that to change.
Earlier this spring, ProPublica broke the news that Justice Clarence Thomas secretly accepted hundreds of thousands of dollars (at a minimum) in travel and vacations from Harlan Crow, an ultra-wealthy supporter of conservative efforts to change the federal judiciary and the law. Thomas, who first met Crow after he joined the court, did not disclose a penny of what ProPublica uncovered, saying later that he thought a “personal hospitality” exemption applied. Thomas presumably referred to his disclosure obligations under the Ethics in Government Act of 1978, which requires public officials — including Supreme Court justices — to report certain gifts so that the public can “follow the money” and evaluate conflicts of interest.
After ProPublica’s reporting, Thomas will amend some disclosure forms to account for a previously undisclosed real estate deal with Crow in 2014 as part of the megadonor’s plans to build a museum to honor Thomas. This is not the first time that Thomas has had to take steps to comply with his transparency obligations after third-party revelations. In 2011, he amended 20 years’ worth of disclosure forms after Common Cause discovered that he had failed to report the source of income for his wife, a political activist.
Why does this matter? It is about much more than Thomas. With each stroke of their pens, Supreme Court justices change the lives of everyday Americans when they decide cases. Both the public and litigants must be able to assess any potential conflicts of interest for themselves. We need to ensure that the people making these decisions are fair and impartial.
A warning sign is blinking that this is not what the public believes. A new poll by NPR, PBS “NewsHour” and Marist found that 6 in 10 respondents had little to no confidence in the court. This continues a dangerous downward trend in public trust in the institution. It comes as the court has issued a series of deeply unpopular opinions to roll back reproductive freedom, gut the Voting Rights Act, and greenlight unlimited corporate spending in elections.
