Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

This story is exclusive to subscribers.

McMinn County, Tennessee, judge declares 2022 ouster petition a ‘fraud’

City of Athens, Tenn. / Former Athens, Tenn., Mayor Bo Perkinson, center, gavels down Council Member Dick Pelley, to his right, during an Aug. 16, 2022, meeting that was the focus of an ouster petition that drew sanctions from a McMinn County Circuit Court judge, who called the petition a fraud. Also shown, left to right, are Council Member Frances Witt-McMahan, former Council Member Mark Lockmiller and Council Member Jordan Curtis.
City of Athens, Tenn. / Former Athens, Tenn., Mayor Bo Perkinson, center, gavels down Council Member Dick Pelley, to his right, during an Aug. 16, 2022, meeting that was the focus of an ouster petition that drew sanctions from a McMinn County Circuit Court judge, who called the petition a fraud. Also shown, left to right, are Council Member Frances Witt-McMahan, former Council Member Mark Lockmiller and Council Member Jordan Curtis.

A McMinn County Circuit Court judge has ordered sanctions against an Athens City Council member and his attorney after calling their 2022 ouster petition seeking to remove a former mayor “a fraud upon this court.”

Athens City Council Member Adolphus “Dick” Pelley, who has held his seat for more than 20 years, filed the ouster petition in August 2022 seeking the removal of then-Mayor Bo Perkinson over allegations Perkinson blocked Pelley from fully participating in an Aug. 16, 2022, council meeting.

Pelley’s petition, filed by Knoxville-based attorney Van R. Irion, included a list naming 17 other people, along with Pelley, as petitioners in the suit against Perkinson. It sought Perkinson’s suspension pending a trial on his ouster.

In his ruling, Circuit Court Judge J. Michael Sharp on Aug. 18 found six or more of the “petitioners” testified Irion was not their lawyer, they didn’t know what the petition sought, hadn’t met Irion until the day they provided testimony considered in Sharp’s order, and when some signed a document to participate, they didn’t know it was to become part of a petition to seek Perkinson’s removal.

There were also discrepancies on the dates the people signed paperwork for the petition — weeks before the disputed meeting even took place.