Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

This story is exclusive to subscribers.

Religious liberty visions collide as Orthodox Jewish group pans Tennessee Jewish foster parents’ lawsuit

Contributed photo / Knox County couple Elizabeth and Gabriel Rutan-Ram allege a publicly funded Christian child-placement agency refused to serve them because they are Jewish — and that a new Tennessee law permitting the policy violates their constitutional rights.
Contributed photo / Knox County couple Elizabeth and Gabriel Rutan-Ram allege a publicly funded Christian child-placement agency refused to serve them because they are Jewish — and that a new Tennessee law permitting the policy violates their constitutional rights.

A national group representing Orthodox Jewish rabbis this week attacked a court decision permitting a Knox County Jewish couple to proceed in a high-profile lawsuit against the state.

The couple is challenging a law that allows state-funded adoption agencies to deny service to prospective parents for religious reasons. The law seemed to apply in January 2021, when the couple said they were denied service by a state-funded Christian adoption agency — Holston United Methodist Home for Children — because they were Jewish.

The couple subsequently sued, alleging unconstitutional religious discrimination that impeded their efforts to foster a child and stigmatized them for being Jewish. A Tennessee appeals court recently ruled the lawsuit could proceed.

Many Jewish groups support the couple’s cause. But in a statement, the Baltimore-based Coalition for Jewish Values, an organization founded in 2017 that says it represents 2,500 Orthodox rabbis, said the adoption law protects religious liberty and the couple’s lawsuit is “crying wolf” on antisemitism.

(READ MORE: Denied service by state-funded Christian group, Jewish foster parents challenge controversial Tennessee law)