When 82-year-old Sue Carol Elvin of Highland Park was a little girl, she caught a yellow butterfly. Later, she released it “back to heaven,” she told her mother. Why? “So it could get more butter.”
In her mind, Elvin can see the butterfly and almost feel its six tiny legs lift off from her open hands.
Yet, part of her knows it’s not a real memory, but simply a story her mother liked to tell. Still, Elvin heard it so often her brain now claims the memory as its personal, eyewitness property.
As we get older, we sort through our memories, edit them and try to make sense of our lives, Elvin believes. But we need not be steered into false nostalgia, believing, like the line from the song, “Life was beautiful then.”
Well, life is sometimes beautiful, but not always beautiful.
