Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg’s dubious prosecution of Donald Trump over his payoffs to a mistress boosted the former president in the Republican primary polls. One of the predictable effects of the decision by the Colorado Supreme Court to kick Trump off the ballot is that it will have the same effect.
Predictable is not, however, the same thing as rational. The court’s decision can be wrong and even outrageous without being a defensible reason for making Trump president again.
Trump supporters sometimes say they feel compelled to support him as a way to stand up to the illegitimate tactics of his opponents: to preserve their freedom to use the political process to choose him as president even as those opponents try to deprive them of that option.
This is deeply unwise. It’s self-defeating, because Republicans who react that way are letting the behavior of Trump’s opponents dictate their votes. And although the opponents have taken extraordinary measures, it’s not simply because they dislike his fans or because Trump is a threat to a nebulously defined establishment. Voters should consider Trump’s conduct at issue in the Colorado suit disqualifying even if it is not the court’s place to say so.
And it isn’t. The Colorado court followed what jurist Robert Bork called the “heart’s desire” school of jurisprudence. The teaching of that school: If you squint at the Constitution from just the right angle, it makes your fondest wish come true. It works for anyone, regardless of their party affiliation or ideology.
