“THE FROZEN RIVER” by Ariel Lawhon (Doubleday, 448 pages, $28).
It’s the winter of 1790, and Rebecca Foster is testifying before the Massachusetts Court of Common Pleas. Refusing to spare her gossip-seeking neighbors the gruesome details, Rebecca recounts the experience of having been raped by two prominent men in the community. One of these men, Joseph North, is a local judge. The other man is now dead; some believe he was murdered.
After Rebecca gives her testimony, the presiding judge asks if she reported the assault. Rebecca answers, “Who could I tell? Judge North is the one who would hear my complaint.” In this moment, Ariel Lawhon’s latest novel, “The Frozen River,” lays bare the troubling paradox belying America’s justice system: Those with the power to write and enforce the law are so often those who need its protection the least, leaving those on the outside with few tools to advocate for themselves.
But “The Frozen River” is a story that champions the outsider, and one of its outsiders is Martha Ballard, the local midwife and Rebecca’s only real ally.
Though integral to her community, Martha is widely disliked because of her demeanor. However, unlike most women at that time, Martha can act as an expert witness in court due to her vocation. Thus, she takes it upon herself to fight for Rebecca. Still, like her peers, Martha cannot testify without her husband present — a rule that seems increasingly absurd the more readers witness Martha’s brilliance and courage — and Judge North is determined to keep Martha’s husband from making it to Rebecca’s trial.
