Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Opinion: Negotiated settlement likely ultimate end to Ukraine war

Valya Kravchun surveys the damage to her neighborhood in Kyiv, Ukraine after a Russian strike on Thursday, Dec. 29, 2022. Explosions rocked towns and cities around Ukraine on Thursday morning, and electricity went out in several regions as Russia launched what appeared to be one its biggest strikes to date on the country’s energy grid. (Laura Boushnak/The New York Times)
Valya Kravchun surveys the damage to her neighborhood in Kyiv, Ukraine after a Russian strike on Thursday, Dec. 29, 2022. Explosions rocked towns and cities around Ukraine on Thursday morning, and electricity went out in several regions as Russia launched what appeared to be one its biggest strikes to date on the country’s energy grid. (Laura Boushnak/The New York Times)

Instead of a quick Russian victory, Russia’s second invasion of Ukraine seems to be settling into a drawn-out slugfest. After Ukrainian soldiers surprisingly thwarted Russia’s offensive on Kyiv, Ukraine’s capital city, the gleeful United States rallied NATO nations to provide the Ukrainians with tens of billions in weapons technology.

After some Ukrainian battlefield successes in throwing back the Russians in the east and south of Ukraine, which gained back some Russian-occupied territory, the United States and its allies gradually succumbed to the vision of decisively handing the Russian Bear with a stinging military defeat.

Yet, Russia still has some advantages. By essentially invading Crimea and parts of industrialized eastern Ukraine in 2014 and combining this conquered territory with that of its initial gains in the east and south in the 2022 invasion, the Russians have given the Ukrainians a Herculean task to recapture such a large land area against a more significant and sometimes well-dug-in occupying force.

Unless the reported low morale of the Russian force causes it to suddenly collapse — as German troops did in 1918 during World War I — the war likely will turn into a long, bloody slog.

Although the West has emotionally rallied to Ukraine’s colors against a more formidable aggressor by providing tens of billions in military, economic and humanitarian aid, the United States now must make a hard-nosed analysis of whether its security requires a clear-cut Ukrainian victory, whether that’s even a realistic possibility, and if not, what a settlement of lands between the two countries would look like to create the best chance for a peaceful solution to the conflict that would endure.