Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Opinion: Kevin McCarthy and the return of the pre-Trump GOP

Photo/Mark Peterson/The New York Times / A live feed from the House chamber shows Rep. Kevin McCarthy, R-Calif., as voting for the next Speaker of the House continued at the Capitol in Washington on Jan. 5, 2023. The failure of the “red wave” in the 2022 midterms and Trump’s subsequent diminishment have had a reverse-wave effect: It’s like watching a wall of water roll backward, exposing the old coastline, the political topography that the water covered up, as NYT columnist Ross Douthat writes.
Photo/Mark Peterson/The New York Times / A live feed from the House chamber shows Rep. Kevin McCarthy, R-Calif., as voting for the next Speaker of the House continued at the Capitol in Washington on Jan. 5, 2023. The failure of the “red wave” in the 2022 midterms and Trump’s subsequent diminishment have had a reverse-wave effect: It’s like watching a wall of water roll backward, exposing the old coastline, the political topography that the water covered up, as NYT columnist Ross Douthat writes.

Did you miss the Republican Party that existed before Donald Trump came along? Are you nostalgic for the days of John Boehner battling tea party rebels over the debt ceiling or the fiscal cliff, or Ted Cruz’s “plan” to defund Obamacare? Do you pine for the years when the crucial test of conservative purity was a commitment to an implausible deficit reduction plan, the good old days when empty suits and aspiring lobbyists battled libertarian ideologues and aspiring cable news personalities for the chance to advance an agenda of mild austerity and business-friendly tax cuts?

Good news, then; those days are back. The failure of the “red wave” in the 2022 midterms and Trump’s subsequent diminishment have had a reverse-wave effect: It’s like watching a wall of water roll backward, exposing the old coastline, the political topography that the water covered up. It’s the old world come again, the GOP ancient regime with all its dysfunctions, stalemates and futility.

In the negotiations over the speakership, it’s been clear that certain pre-Trump patterns are still resilient. On one side, embodied now by McCarthy and his allies, you have a GOP establishment trying to run the House in a centralized fashion without any particular vision or agenda. On the other, in the factions that resisted his speakership, you have conservatives with a lot of legitimate complaints about process joined to a policy vision that’s mostly performative gestures and fiscal apocalypticism. The likely result, as in the tea party era, is a Congress incapable of governing, save through last-minute brinkmanship and a conservatism.

Part of Trump’s original success rested on the way he freed the Republican Party from this dead end. He did this in a demagogic style, but his promises — to bring back jobs lost to China and build new highways, to protect Social Security while ending illegal immigration — helped the GOP slip out of its Barack Obama-era trap, where the congressional party appeared to be obsessed with unpopular spending cuts but also was rarely capable of driving any bargains to achieve them.

For the House GOP today, an equivalent escape is imaginable. Its majority could be used to pass a series of messaging bills on issues where conservatives have, or might have, an advantage with the public: a crime bill, a border security bill, reforms to academic funding and tax breaks and school standards that aim to weaken the elite-college cartel and influence the educational culture wars, some version of the pro-family policies that anti-abortion groups have pushed for in the wake of Dobbs. In each case, the goal would be to position the party on ground where the concerns of activists and independent voters might overlap and set the GOP up for success in 2024.