Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Review: Goodfellas in Chattanooga is a place for wiseguys to find a great pizza

Photo by Anne Braly / Goodfellas' signature meatball sub, known as the Al Pacino, serves up a deliciously gooey blend of meatballs, marinara sauce and mozzarella on a New York Tribeca bun.
Photo by Anne Braly / Goodfellas' signature meatball sub, known as the Al Pacino, serves up a deliciously gooey blend of meatballs, marinara sauce and mozzarella on a New York Tribeca bun.

It was a cold, rainy Monday when I paid a visit to Goodfellas Pizzeria. It was shortly after noon — the height of the lunch hour. I knew they might have a couple of customers, but considering the winter weather and it being a Monday, I didn’t think it would be very crowded. Was I ever wrong.

Goodfellas, a Lexington, Kentucky-based chain, opened in downtown Chattanooga in 2020, right as you-know-what hit the planet. Not the best time for any business to open. But maybe this was perfect timing, giving the pizzeria a couple of years to establish itself as the go-to pizza place in a town that has pizza parlors at every turn.

So in I went and looked around for someone to guide me in the right direction. No such luck. I was on my own, but figured out very quickly that this is a place where you do lot of the legwork yourself, from ordering to finding a table and getting your own drink. That done, I got in a line about eight people deep.


THE MENU