Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Opinion: Republican debates are a recipe for chaos

File photo/Marcus Yam/The New York Times / A cameraman is seen behind the scene of the Republican presidential debate at the Marshall Student Center at the University of South Florida in Tampa, Fla., on Jan. 23, 2012. To participate in the first Republican presidential debate on Aug. 23, 2023, candidates must meet challenging new criteria, including having at least 40,000 donors and voter support of at least 1% in three approved polls; but the requirement causing the most consternation is a pledge to support the eventual nominee.
File photo/Marcus Yam/The New York Times / A cameraman is seen behind the scene of the Republican presidential debate at the Marshall Student Center at the University of South Florida in Tampa, Fla., on Jan. 23, 2012. To participate in the first Republican presidential debate on Aug. 23, 2023, candidates must meet challenging new criteria, including having at least 40,000 donors and voter support of at least 1% in three approved polls; but the requirement causing the most consternation is a pledge to support the eventual nominee.

With the first Republican presidential debate scheduled for Aug. 23 rapidly approaching, it’s becoming increasingly clear that the institutions and practices for choosing presidential nominees are a terrible fit for the choices the party has to make.

This is perhaps easiest to see in the loyalty pledge that the Republican National Committee is requiring candidates make in order to participate in the debates. The pledge to support whoever wins the nomination has already meant that Trump critic Will Hurd apparently won’t be allowed to participate. It also puts any other anti-Trump candidate, such as former New Jersey Governor Chris Christie, in the nonsensical position of arguing that Trump is unfit for the office, yet he would still support the former president should he be nominated.

Indeed, the pledge institutionalizes as the Republican Party’s official position that neither attempting to overturn an election nor being indicted for multiple felonies is disqualifying for the presidency and that anyone who believes otherwise will be cut off from party leadership.

The pledge was originally instituted in 2016 as a way of challenging Trump when he was polling well but still not seen as the likely nominee. This time around it works to his advantage. He’ll no doubt agree to the pledge if he decides to attend any debates. If he loses the nomination, he’ll just declare the pledge void because he’ll claim everything was rigged and the nomination stolen from him.

At the same time, Trump still hasn’t committed to participate in any of the debates, including the first one. And that’s reasonable. Right now he’s the heavy favorite for the nomination, well ahead in the polls and in high-profile endorsements. Political strategists have long believed that front runners have little to gain and plenty to lose by debating. That’s why no incumbent president has ever debated any nomination challenger. Trump isn’t the incumbent, but as a former president and two-time nominee he’s as close as it gets. Indeed, previous strong leaders in the year before the election such as Al Gore in 2000, George W. Bush in 2000, and Hillary Clinton in 2016 have either skipped early debates or successfully pushed back the first debate.