Skip to main content
Tuesday, November 17, 2026Nov 17

Opinion: Why Medicaid expansion will overcome politics in holdout states

Photo/Gary D. Robertson/The Associated Press / Democratic members of the North Carolina House pose for a picture on the House floor after the chamber gave final approval to a Medicaid expansion agreement in Raleigh, N.C., on Thursday, March 23, 2023. The affirmative vote means the legislation laying out expansion details now goes to the desk of Democratic Gov. Roy Cooper.
Photo/Gary D. Robertson/The Associated Press / Democratic members of the North Carolina House pose for a picture on the House floor after the chamber gave final approval to a Medicaid expansion agreement in Raleigh, N.C., on Thursday, March 23, 2023. The affirmative vote means the legislation laying out expansion details now goes to the desk of Democratic Gov. Roy Cooper.

North Carolina’s Republican-led legislature last week approved the expansion of Medicaid to more low-income adults, leaving only 10 states [including Tennessee] that continue to reject the federal government’s incentives under the Affordable Care Act. Medicaid expansion, aimed at adults who make too much money to qualify for conventional Medicaid but not enough to receive subsidized insurance through ACA marketplaces, has had a bigger effect than any other policy in reducing the country’s uninsured population. Expect the last 10 states, most of which are strongly Republican, to eventually sign on, too.

That’s not the way things normally work in this era of partisan polarization, where the nation is moving to two sets of laws, one for Republican states and one for their Democratic counterparts, on many policy questions where the federal government allows choice. We no longer expect California and Texas to converge voluntarily on the same abortion policy or the same rules about labor rights or the same laws about school choice. And yet North Carolina now joins Idaho, Arkansas and several other Republican states in adopting the reform. And it’s just a matter of time before Texas, Florida and the others join in.

The steady adoption of Medicaid expansion has occurred even though the ACA, otherwise known as Obamacare, continues to be unpopular among Republicans.

For a major policy reform, Medicaid expansion’s staying power is unusual. Indeed, legislatures in political battlegrounds regularly repeal laws adopted when the other party was in charge. Michigan’s newly Democratic legislature just passed a repeal of a right-to-work law adopted in 2012 by Republican majorities after the last GOP landslide in that state; Republicans will surely re-reverse it the next time they win big in state elections.

But Republican victories giving them control of statehouses over the last decade haven’t produced a single repeal of Medicaid expansion; in fact, GOP lawmakers rarely even try, given the damage it would do to state finances.