Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Target and Best Buy are unexpected underdogs this critical holiday season

Nicole Leary, of Edina, Minnesota, takes a photo of her daughter Sloane, 8, right, and niece Teagan Swanson , 9, as they pose with a mannequin of Target mascot "Bullseye" during Black Friday shopping Friday, Nov. 25, 2022, at Target in Edina. (Aaron Lavinsky/Minneapolis Star Tribune/TNS)
Nicole Leary, of Edina, Minnesota, takes a photo of her daughter Sloane, 8, right, and niece Teagan Swanson , 9, as they pose with a mannequin of Target mascot "Bullseye" during Black Friday shopping Friday, Nov. 25, 2022, at Target in Edina. (Aaron Lavinsky/Minneapolis Star Tribune/TNS)

Target and Best Buy find themselves in an unusual spot this holiday season: fighting to retain market share during a season they usually dominate.

The last months of the year are especially critical to Target, which has lost customers to Walmart and other stores this year.

Both of the Minnesota-based national retailers already tamped down any expectations that they will have a blockbuster holiday season — a period that produces an outsize percentage of their profits.

“I think everyone is cautious about the holiday. … Whether it’s about market share or just the consumer not spending on discretionary, I guess we’ll see,” said Diya Iyer, S&P Global Ratings retail director. “Even the ones who have gained market share aren’t guiding to a very positive holiday.”

What’s more, the season this year will test the resilience of a modern retail business model that Target and Best Buy for the most part built and that allowed them to surge during the pandemic.