A lingering legal battle poised to settle this summer, leading to a clearer pathway for tens of thousands of Tennesseans to restore their voting rights, has instead reignited into a contentious court fight with no certain outcome ahead of the next presidential election.
One in 5 Black voting-age Tennesseans lacks the right to vote due to a past criminal conviction — likely the highest rate of African American disenfranchisement in the nation, according to the Sentencing Project, a Washington, D.C.-based group that advocates for restoration of voting rights and ending extreme sentences. Overall, nearly 10% of the Tennessee electorate — 470,000 people — have lost their right to vote due to convictions.
In a lawsuit filed in December 2020, the Tennessee Conference of the NAACP and five residents denied the right to vote alleged Tennessee officials failed to follow state laws that allow individuals to legally restore their voting rights after serving their sentences and completing parole. Instead, the state implemented inaccessible and opaque processes that impede legal pathways for restoring rights, the lawsuit claimed.
Close to settling key claims in the case over the summer — potentially ahead of high profile local elections in Nashville, Memphis and for state office — attorneys for the state abruptly broke off talks in late July, catching lawyers for the NAACP by surprise, legal filings show. Then, on Aug. 2, lawyers for the Tennessee Attorney General’s Office filed motions asking a judge to reject the claims entirely.
