Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Why can’t unbeaten James Madison appear in the CFP rankings? It’s not an option for the Dukes

James Madison defensive lineman Jalen Green (10) celebrates after the team's NCAA college football game against Old Dominion on Saturday, Oct. 28, 2023, in Harrisonburg, Va. (AP Photo/Mike Caudill)
James Madison defensive lineman Jalen Green (10) celebrates after the team's NCAA college football game against Old Dominion on Saturday, Oct. 28, 2023, in Harrisonburg, Va. (AP Photo/Mike Caudill)

The College Football Playoff rankings will be released for the first time this season on Tuesday night and there is one unbeaten team guaranteed to be left out of the selection committee’s top 25.

James Madison (8-0), ranked No. 23 in the AP Top 25, is ineligible for postseason play as it completes an NCAA-required transition period to the highest level of Division I football, the Bowl Subdivision. Since the CFP rankings are solely to determine postseason assignments for two playoff games and four marquee bowls, the Dukes are ineligible to be ranked.

James Madison officials are still hoping the NCAA will make an exception to allow the Dukes to play in the postseason, but they are not particularly optimistic. JMU’s most likely road to a bowl will be as a replacement in a lower-level postseason game if there are not enough teams that meet the typical eligibility standard of six wins and a .500 record.

Still, the Dukes are good enough to at least be in the conversation for a bigger prize — a place in the New Year’s Six Bowls that is reserved for the CFP’s highest-ranked champion from a so-called Group of Five conference at the end of the regular season.

That spot will be in the Fiesta Bowl this season and comes with a $4 million payout to the conference of the team that earns it.