Four Catoosa County Republicans, three of whom are incumbent county representatives, will remain on the ballot for the May 21 primary election, a federal judge has ruled.
But that’s not the end of the story.
Although Judge William M. Ray III, an appointee of former President Donald Trump, allowed the four to stay on the ballot because it was “too close to the election” and could lead to possible confusion and disenfranchisement of voters, he did not rule on whether the Catoosa County Republican Party had the right to boot them from the ballot, based on the First Amendment right to free association.
The county party originally had said Larry Black, chair of the County Commission; Vanita Hullander, the District 3 commissioner; Jeff Long, the District 1 representative; and Steven Henry, a former chair of the commission and a candidate for the same position, could not be on the primary ballot because they weren’t true Republicans. They, arguing they had been elected as Republicans, sued to reverse that determination.
A Superior Court judge, in turn, ordered the county’s elections director to put the names on the ballots. The county party and chair Joanna Hildreth then sued the county elections director and elections board in federal court. That, in turn, led to Ray’s ruling.
