A Hamilton County jury could reasonably believe or disbelieve the testimony of Fred Sails, who was the sole witness to testify about a 2021 fatal shooting that happened inside his home, according to Judge Barry Steelman.
Marvin Lebron Fallins Sr., 54, is accused of fatally shooting Frank Usher, 29, in the neck.
Fallins’ attorney, David MacNeill, argued the shooting was done in self-defense.
The incident happened March 5, 2021, in Sails’ kitchen on the 700 block of E. 48th St. Sails and Fallins are lifelong friends.
Fallins was initially charged with first-degree murder in connection with Usher’s death, but jurors were instructed that second-degree murder was the highest charge they could return as a verdict.




